agentcocoon

Guides

Which old Shopify blog posts are worth restoring after a migration?

By Drew Amato · Published

Restore the small set of posts that earned most of your search clicks before the move, plus any post that leads straight to something you sell, at their exact old URLs. Redirect every other post to the closest live page on the same topic, not the home page. For us that was 12 of 75 posts, which carried 79% of the old blog's impressions and 65% of its clicks.

When Mully moved off Shopify, the old blog quietly stopped working. Shopify still held all 97 articles, but every /blogs/news/ URL on the new site returned a 404. Our SEO agent found that 75 of those posts had drawn 156,000 Google impressions in the two months before the move. (The full story of the drop is in why Google traffic drops after moving off Shopify.)

We did not bring back all 75. This guide covers how we chose, what we did with the rest, and what Search Console shows so far.

Why not just restore every old post?

Because most old posts earn almost nothing, and each restored page is one more page to maintain. A dead URL does not wait for you, either. Google drops URLs that return a 4xx code from its index over time (Google Search Central), so the goal is to get the posts that matter back fast, then handle the long tail with redirects.

How do you pick which posts to bring back?

Rank them by what they earned before the move, and look at clicks, not just impressions. Here is the top of our list, from Search Console for March and April:

Post Impressions Clicks Click rate
How the Official World Golf Rankings work 56,385 12 0.02%
How a golf handicap is calculated 19,997 10 0.05%
How to stop hitting the ball off the hosel 17,979 264 1.47%
Best formats for golf trips with your buddies 6,945 114 1.64%
Golf formats explained 6,213 26 0.42%

Sorted by impressions, the rankings post looks like the prize. Sorted by clicks, two posts did almost all the work: the hosel fix and the golf trip formats sent 378 of the 477 clicks across all 12 posts we restored. Impressions tell you Google showed the page. Clicks tell you someone wanted it.

We used three tests:

  1. Earned traffic. Keep adding posts in order until you cover most of the old blog's results. The 12 we restored covered 79% of impressions (123,000 of 156,000) and 65% of clicks.
  2. Leads somewhere you sell. Our 12th post, a golf outing planning guide from January, had only 66 impressions. We kept it because it feeds our group outings page, which is something we sell.
  3. Still true. A post about a rule change or a product you no longer carry is better redirected than restored.

Where should the other posts redirect?

To the closest live page on the same topic, with a permanent redirect. Google recommends permanent server-side redirects from each old URL to its mapped new URL, and warns that sending many old URLs to one irrelevant page, like the home page, can be treated as a soft 404 (Google Search Central). A 301 or 308 also tells Google the new page should be the one it shows (Google Search Central).

Our 63 redirects, grouped by topic:

Old posts Count Redirected to
Subscription box comparisons 6 Our current comparison post
Mully promo posts 5 The subscription page
Gift guides 8 The gift page
Gear and training posts 6 Our curated gear list
Topics covered by a newer post 4 That live blog post
Topics covered by a restored post 4 The restored post
Dated posts with little traffic 21 The blog index

The remaining 9 went to the shop or a matching collection. The 21 sent to the blog index are the weakest part of the map, and we kept that bucket to posts with almost no history.

What does a restored post need besides the old text?

The exact old URL and a clean page. What our website agent did for each one:

  1. Same URL, new design. /blogs/news/ stays, rendered in the current Journal template with a "From the archive" label.
  2. Strip the old blog app. The original posts carried scripts and styles injected by a Shopify blog app. The body is cleaned down to plain text, headings, lists, links and images.
  3. Fix links inside the post. Old internal links to /products/ or other old posts are rewritten to their final URL, so readers never hit a redirect chain.
  4. One next step. Each post ends with a single card tied to its topic. The hosel post points to training aids, the trip formats post to group outings.
  5. Self canonical and in the sitemap. Each restored URL points to itself and is listed in the new sitemap.
  6. Test before release. On the preview site, every old URL had to resolve to a live page in two hops or fewer, with no loops.

How fast do restored posts come back?

Slower than you would like, and one at a time. The restore went live on October 28. In the 11 days after that, Search Console shows one restored post with impressions: the hosel fix, with 927 impressions and 14 clicks at an average position of 5.5. Before the move, it averaged about 295 impressions a day. It is back at roughly 84, a bit under 30%.

The other 11 restored posts have shown no impressions yet. Google says a small to medium site can take a few weeks for most pages to move, and recommends keeping redirects for at least a year (Google Search Central). The post that came back first is also the one that earned the most clicks before the move. Check the rest weekly before deciding a restore failed.

Common questions

Should restored posts keep the old Shopify design?

No. Keep the old URL and the old words, and put them in your current design. Ours use the new Journal layout with an "archive" label, a cleaned body and one card pointing to a page we sell from.

Is it better to restore a post or rewrite it?

Restore first, at the same URL, so Google sees the page it already ranked come back. Rewrite later once it is back in results. Changing the URL and the content at the same time makes it harder to tell what worked.

Can I redirect old posts to my blog index?

For a handful of dated posts with almost no traffic, it is a reasonable last resort. Google warns that sending many old URLs to one unrelated page can be treated as a soft 404, so give every post with a clear topic a specific target first.

How long do the redirects need to stay?

Google says at least a year, and from a visitor's point of view, indefinitely. Old links in emails, forums and AI answers keep getting clicked long after the move.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central: Site moves with URL changes
  2. Google Search Central: HTTP status codes and Google Search
  3. Google Search Central: Redirects and Google Search

About the author. Drew Amato is the founder of Mully, a golf apparel brand in Detroit, and of AgentCocoon. He builds and runs the AI agents behind Mully's own operations. Follow on X.